Examiner's comment
Decision analysis is a relatively new topic in the specification, so it was pleasing to see a good number of excellent solutions. Whilst many candidates interpreted the question correctly a substantial minority were unable to draw a correct decision tree. Candidates are advised to learn the style for the three types of node: boxes for decision nodes, circles for chance nodes and triangles for end pay-off nodes, with the former two drawn sufficiently large to allow figures to be entered inside them. For this problem the optimum structure consists of nine end pay-off nodes, three chance nodes and one decision nodes. A few candidates used an alternative correct structure, with six chance nodes, which overcomplicated the solution, necessitating the recalculation of several probabilities, and completion of additional intermediate chance nodes. Of those that constructed a correct tree diagram, many were then unable to annotate it correctly, in spite of showing the correct travel time calculations elsewhere in their solution. Both chance and decision nodes must have their calculated values entered inside them. All arcs must be appropriately labelled. Two short double lines through arcs should be used to indicate inferior options, though just on this occasion single lines or crosses were not penalised. A few candidates used negative values to indicate delays, and were not penalised this time, but again this would not be condoned in future.