Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)

Examiner's comment
This question required candidates to conduct a test to see whether two variances were the same. Candidates found this question more challenging, so it was rare for full marks to be achieved, usually part (b) being where marks were not scored. Part (b) was rarely fully correct. Candidates often did not fully answer (b)(i) which required an explanation regarding the importance of the conclusion to the test in (a) with respect to the test carried out on the difference between two means. Just stating you can find a pooled estimate for the population variance was not sufficient without explaining that the variances were equal was a required assumption to carry out the t-test. Some candidates also did not correctly interpret the significance of the p-value, whilst others did not correctly mention the effect on the mean yield (instead of just ‘yield’).
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
- (i) the pooled two-sample t-test REQUIRES equal population variances, which (a) supports
- just 'can pool' is not enough
- (ii) p = 0.002 is very small: evidence the bacteria increase MEAN yield


