Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)

Examiner's comment
(i) Part (a) the majority of candidates were able to identify the identity element. Part (b) many candidates did not many to find the inverse of b c , mistaking thinking that instead of a. Candidates who did find b c correctly found the inverse. b c e a = = Part (c) Candidates where able to explain why the set of 4 elements cannot be a subgroup of G, The majority said that it does not satisfy Lagrange’s Theorem, with some showing that closure fails as e.g. a a is not in the set. d = ° Part (d) To show that the set { } , , is a subgroup of G candidates needed to find the Cayley b d f table and concluded that it is closed, b and f are inverses and d is the identity, so the subset is a subgroup. Many candidates only showed the result for a few products so not able to prove closure and gained only 1 mark. (ii) This part was found very demanding by the majority of candidates, with many making no 5 yx xy 3 2 3 attempt. A few candidates scored a method mark for using the relation once on = y xy x but made no further progress. There were only 2 candidates who managed to successfully that 3 2 3 y xy x is the identity.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
- the identity is d (its row and column repeat the borders)



