CP6.3 Calculate the scalar product and use it to express the equation of…
Section
CP6 Further vectors
Level
AS & A level
Statement
Calculate the scalar product and use it to express the equation of a plane, and to calculate the angle between two lines, the angle between two planes and the angle between a line and a plane.
June 2025 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q10(a)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
In part (a), the vast majority of the learners recognised the need to equate the scalar product of the two normal vectors to zero and thus correctly found the value of a.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
normals perpendicular: (1, 1, −1).(a, 3, 5) = a − 2 = 0, a = 2
June 2025 · Paper 2 (Core Pure 2) · Q2(c)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
In contrast to question 1, this was very well answered overall, proving to be an accessible vector model question, which traditionally causes problems. The context was straightforward enough to not obscure what was needed and learners made good progress with many identifying the shortcoming of the model at the end. Learners were slightly less successful in part (c), though still the majority made good progress. Learners were more likely to use incorrect vectors than in earlier parts, for example using the anchor point of the line rather than the direction vector in the scalar product and so losing all three marks. But many were successful in applying the formula with correct vectors and to produce either the angle or it complement. Many used sin theta directly when calculating the required angle, and these responses were almost always correct. Candidates who found cos theta first sometimes gave their final answer as 18°, either forgetting to subtract the value from 90° or not realising which angle they were being asked for.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
angle between the direction (3, 3, −1) and the normal (2, 4, −1), then 90° minus it (or use sin): 72°
using the position vector instead of the direction scored 0
June 2024 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q2(e)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Part a) was often answered incorrectly and candidates failed to check their value worked consistently, common incorrect answers included 30 and 150 . ± Part b) was attempted by most students who recognised the need for alpha to be divisible exactly k by 360, it was common to see attempts involving trial and error or calculator use. The odd value of k however not the lowest. Many students who got 300 and 1500 in part a) were able to attempt at finding the LCM of alpha and 360 was seen which were generally successful in finding a calculate k, scoring M1A0. Part c) was very well answered with the large majority achieving this mark. It was pleasing to see candidates that although maybe couldn’t access a) and b) continued to read through the question and pick up marks here. Part d) was a show that question and whilst many candidates appreciated the need for matrix multiplication and furthermore understood the necessary order many failed to show evidence of matrix multiplication which was not sufficient. Those who did show their working generally did so correctly and were able to proceed to the correct answer. Some students left their answer as a vector which was condoned in this question. Candidates who drew a sketch were more successful in part e and f than those who didn’t. It was common to see both the cosine rule and scalar product used in part e), most candidates who selected a correct method were able to proceed to the final answer. Numerical and sign errors were more common when using the cosine rule and calculating AB . Part f) was generally well done although some candidates selected the wrong side and used AB in place of OA or OB, again a sketch helped with this. A small number of candidates failed to round to the required level of accuracy in e) and f) losing the final mark.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
OA.OB = 6√3 + 1 with both lengths √29 (rotation and reflection preserve length)
cos AOB = (6√3 + 1)/29
66.9°
June 2024 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q2(f)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Part a) was often answered incorrectly and candidates failed to check their value worked consistently, common incorrect answers included 30 and 150 . ± Part b) was attempted by most students who recognised the need for alpha to be divisible exactly k by 360, it was common to see attempts involving trial and error or calculator use. The odd value of k however not the lowest. Many students who got 300 and 1500 in part a) were able to attempt at finding the LCM of alpha and 360 was seen which were generally successful in finding a calculate k, scoring M1A0. Part c) was very well answered with the large majority achieving this mark. It was pleasing to see candidates that although maybe couldn’t access a) and b) continued to read through the question and pick up marks here. Part d) was a show that question and whilst many candidates appreciated the need for matrix multiplication and furthermore understood the necessary order many failed to show evidence of matrix multiplication which was not sufficient. Those who did show their working generally did so correctly and were able to proceed to the correct answer. Some students left their answer as a vector which was condoned in this question. Candidates who drew a sketch were more successful in part e and f than those who didn’t. It was common to see both the cosine rule and scalar product used in part e), most candidates who selected a correct method were able to proceed to the final answer. Numerical and sign errors were more common when using the cosine rule and calculating AB . Part f) was generally well done although some candidates selected the wrong side and used AB in place of OA or OB, again a sketch helped with this. A small number of candidates failed to round to the required level of accuracy in e) and f) losing the final mark.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
area = ½ × √29 × √29 × sin 66.9° = 13.3
June 2024 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q6(c)3 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
In part (c), there was much success in finding the acute angle between the pipes with the use of the scalar product being the most common method in this procedure.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
directions (5, 12, 1) and (2, 4, −2): cos θ = 56/(√170√24)
28.8°
June 2024 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q7(b)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Although vectors is not a favoured topic with candidates the first three parts of this question proved accessible to most, with the final part discriminating between the better candidates. Notation throughout was generally very good, with either column vectors or the i, j and k forms used, or coordinates where appropriate. For part (b) the method mark was almost always scored by those who made some attempt at the part, though a few did use one of the direction vectors instead of a point on the line. There was the occasional arithmetic error, for example reaching 26 rather than 20, but usually the calculation was correct. The accuracy was also often lost by a candidate leaving their answer in vector rather than Cartesian form, not adhering to the instruction in the question.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
r.n = a.n using a point on l₁ (not a direction vector): 3x − 10y − z = 20
June 2024 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q7(d)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Although vectors is not a favoured topic with candidates the first three parts of this question proved accessible to most, with the final part discriminating between the better candidates. Notation throughout was generally very good, with either column vectors or the i, j and k forms used, or coordinates where appropriate. Part (d) was more challenging, and many were unable to see the way forward. Those who knew the process required usually carried it out correctly, but many only proceeded as far as finding the coordinates of point A. Indeed, most were able to complete the process to find the point A, wisely using the first and third ordinates to solve, and usually obtained the correct point, though some mixed up the variables after having found and correctly, while others used their incorrect p to find the coordinates instead of realising the other equation did not depend on p so would still yield a correct answer. Having obtained the point A most then realised AB was needed but did not make further progress, having not recalled the method for finding the angle between the line and plane. Those who did know the method would generally score the next two method marks and score at least three marks. However, it was fairly common for a candidate to lose the accuracy mark despite an otherwise correct process. Common slips were: arithmetic errors in calculating the coordinates of point A; arithmetic errors in calculating the vector AB; getting an angle of 50° using arccos, but then forgetting to then find by subtracting from 90°. Candidates who recalled the formula involving arcsin were more successful in attaining the correct answer rounding to 40°.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
find A from two components of l₁ = l₂ first
A = (5.6, 0.3, −6.2)
angle with the plane uses sin, or 90° minus the angle with the normal: 40° (50° from arccos is a common slip)
many stopped at A
June 2023 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q6(b)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This was another good question with the first three parts being accessed by the majority with part (d) providing a good level of challenge. In part (b), this part was also well answered although some candidates left their answer as a scalar equation, other errors were to attempt the Cartesian equation of a line. Those who proceeded to a cartesian equation most likely did so correctly with either achieving 2 3 2 x y z + - = or 2 3 2 0 x y z + - - = In part (c), those who obtained both marks in (b) typically also obtained the mark here, it was pleasing to see that most gave a minimal conclusion, though that was not necessary for this mark.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
leaving it in vector form or giving a line equation lost marks
June 2023 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q5(b)5 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question yielded a varied range of mark profiles and also saw a wide variety of methods employed in the different parts of the question. In part (b), the majority of candidates executed their solutions competently to achieve the given result. Most set up the equation of a new line using the normal to the plane and a point on the given line (usually (–5, -4, 3)) and attempted to find the value of their parameter where this line met the plane. They then proceeded to find the image point and the equation of the line as required. Those who had used an initial point other than (-5, -4, 3) generally realised that their resulting direction vector was a multiple of the required direction vector. When writing the equation of the reflected line, a significant number did not write “r =” (despite it being a given result), either omitting it entirely or writing e.g. l2 = . This omission lost them the final accuracy mark. A relatively small number of candidates identified a point on l1 and found the perpendicular distance from this point to the plane. Many did not progress any further, but some went on to gain full marks by considering the modulus of the normal to the plane which in turn enabled them to identify the image point and ultimately the equation of the line as required. A few candidates found the angle between the line and the plane, but this very rarely resulted in any creditworthy work.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
line through (−5, −4, 3) along the normal meets the plane at t = 2, so the mirror image point is (3, 8, −5)
direction from (−7, 2, −7)
must write r = for the given answer
June 2023 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q5(c)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question yielded a varied range of mark profiles and also saw a wide variety of methods employed in the different parts of the question. In part (c), relatively few students used their working from part (b) to establish a second point on the line of intersection of the two planes, which enabled the equation of the line of intersection to be found very efficiently. Instead, there was a wide variety of (quite time consuming) attempts, many using a vector cross product to find the vector equation of the second plane and solve this simultaneously with the first. Many such attempts, however, stopped short of providing a vector equation of a line and so did not score any marks. Often seen amongst the successful attempts was the relatively efficient method of using the vector product twice; first using the direction vectors of the two reflected lines to find the normal to plane 2, then once again using this normal vector with the normal to plane 1 to find the direction vector of the line of intersection. The vector product is not on the specification, but its use was entirely acceptable.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
best: the point found in (b) on the line through (−5, −4, 3) gives a second common point
r = (−7, 2, −7) + λ(1, 0, 1) o.e.
many lengthy vector-product attempts never reached a line equation
June 2022 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q6(c)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question, which required candidates to work with a model of a tennis ball, proved quite challenging for candidates and tested their ability to apply vector methods to a real-life scenario. There was a great deal of confusion between the position vector of the tennis ball and the direction vector for which it was moving, and less confident students mixed these up frequently. Marks in part (c) varied between no marks, full marks, and just the second method mark, but of these, full marks was the least common. The vast majority of candidates were able to identify that they needed to use . cos theta = a b a b but the choice of vectors used varied quite dramatically. It was clear that as the equation of the plane was not given explicitly a number of candidates found it impossible to access this question as they had no directional vector for the normal. For those candidates that did attempt to use the scalar product most used their answer to (b), but the second vector was frequently one of ( ) 1,1,0 or ( ) 0,1,0 or the position vector particle at their λ from (a). These candidates typically evaluated the dot product and distances correctly for their vectors and scored the second method mark only. Of those that used a correct combination of vectors, the most common approach was using ( ) 0,0,1 , with other methods seen rarely. These candidates typically went on to score full marks, although occasionally incomplete methods were seen: stopping before the acute angle with the plane had been found or 7.49 was given as an answer, without the requested level of accuracy in the question.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
angle with the ground: between (2.56, 15, −2) and k then 90° minus, or with (2.56, 15, 0)
7.5°
wrong choice of vectors common
June 2022 · Paper 2 (Core Pure 2) · Q8(a)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question on a vector model was well-answered although completely correct solutions across all question parts were not that common. Most knew how to use the scalar product to set up an equation in part (a) although the acute angle between the flight paths was used on occasion. Most solved their equation correctly but many responses did not identify that it was the negative value of a that was required.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
scalar product of the direction vectors with cos 120° = −½
squaring gives a² = 4 and a = −2 must be chosen (many did not reject +2)
using the acute angle 60° was an error
June 2022 · Paper 3A (Further Pure 1) · Q3(a)3 marksMedium
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Vectors is never a popular topic, and with only 35% achieving the modal full marks, this question proved less accessible than its position on the paper suggests it should be, with better access for questions 4 and 6 (the other vector question) being seen. Scores of 7 and 8 were also common, with a more even spread across other marks. In many cases one or two errors were made, but the parts they were made in varied a lot. Part (a) perhaps caused the greatest difficulty, with a number of candidates unsure of which vectors to use. The magnitude of OB was usually found correctly and though most candidates could then form a correct equation from the information given, there were many who did not set up a suitable equation, instead attempting the scalar product of with O O B A . The most common accuracy error involved candidates failing to find the negative solution when square rooting. The value of cos 45º was sometimes incorrectly evaluated and mistakes were common in the manipulation of the equation to arrive at a value for p.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
direction cosine 4 / modulus of OB = cos 45°, modulus √(17 + 4p²)
p = ±√15/2
negative root often lost
dot product with OA wrongly used
Nov 2021 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q7(b)2 marksMedium
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
There was a step up in difficulty from this question in the paper, perhaps a tail off towards the end of the exam, but the performance was not as high on the next questions. For this question 51% for the M mark in (b) was the best performing trait, and the only one over 50% scored. (b) This was very better attempted, though surprisingly not as well done as might have been expected. A little over half scored the M for knowing the correct procedure, with just over 40% scoring both marks.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
r.n = a.n: 2x + 3y − 4z = 7
Oct 2020 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q4(b)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
It was pleasing to see that the large majority of candidates attempted at least parts of this question. Part (b) (i) and (ii) were not so successful. The large majority attempted the main scheme though just under half failed to show the vector was perpendicular to both direction vectors. A small number of candidates attempted alternate 1 or 2 method, all being successful in gaining the method mark but not having a conclusion lost them the accuracy mark.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
(i) scalar product with BOTH direction vectors = 0, then conclude perpendicular (about half showed only one)
(ii) r.(1, 2, −10) = a.(1, 2, −10): x + 2y − 10z = 2
Oct 2020 · AS Paper 2 (Further Pure 1) · Q5(a)3 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Part (a) was answered well by the majority of candidates. The application of the vector product was well known although some candidates reverted to trigonometric methods such as the cosine rule to find one of the angles and then went on to find the area. Such methods often lost the final mark for not working in exact terms to convincingly proved the given result. In part (b)
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
½ modulus of DE × DF = ½√(1² + 7² + 17²) = ½√339
trigonometric (cosine rule) routes must stay exact
Oct 2020 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q4(a)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
(a) There were some pleasing responses to this vector question, with many gaining full marks. A popular approach to finding the normal vector to the plane was to use the vector product, although there were a few sign errors. The rest used a scalar product method to find the normal. A few used the Cartesian forms to eliminate one of the scalar parameters, although these often got bogged down with the algebra. Some gave the final answer in scalar product form, losing the last A mark. There were many who were very confused and gained no marks in (a) use this method. Those who had not managed to do part (a) were still able to gain full marks (c) Provided they had found a normal to their plane in part (a), they were then able to apply a correct scalar product method to find the angle between the two planes. However, a few went on to find the wrong angle after a correct application of the dot product, by subtracting from90º. Some were very confused here and methods which were not considering the normal vectors to each plane gained no marks.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
normal by cross product or scalar products: n = 4i + j + 2k
r.n = a.n gives 4x + y + 2z = 10 (Cartesian, not r.n form)
sign errors in the cross product
Oct 2020 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q4(c)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
(c) Provided they had found a normal to their plane in part (a), they were then able to apply a correct scalar product method to find the angle between the two planes. However, a few went on to find the wrong angle after a correct application of the dot product, by subtracting from90º. Some were very confused here and methods which were not considering the normal vectors to each plane gained no marks.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
angle between the normals: cos θ = 13/(√21 √14), θ = 41°
do not subtract from 90°
Oct 2020 · Paper 3A (Further Pure 1) · Q3(b)2 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question was a routine application of the vector product and scalar triple product and there were few candidates who were unable to achieve a good proportion of the marks available. Errors were mainly sign errors and arithmetic errors with an occasional Cartesian equation given in part b rather than the required vector equation, and vector OD being used as the third vector or a missing factor of 1/6 in part c.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
n from (a) with a point on the plane: r.(2i + 4j − 5k) = −7 (or r.(−8i − 16j + 20k) = 28)
Cartesian equation given instead of the vector form
June 2019 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q45 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
substitute the parametric line into r.(1, −2, 1) = −7: 0λ − 8 = −7, a contradiction so no intersection
l is parallel to Π but not in it
or direction.normal = 0 then test a point
June 2019 · AS Paper 2 (Further Pure 1) · Q4(a)4 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
Q4 was accessible to most candidates, but it was clear that there were a few candidates who had not revised the vector cross product formula. In Q4(a), most candidates found the area of triangle ABC by applying the method 1 . 2 AB AC Some candidates found the correct answer by applying the vector cross product between two other edges of triangle ABC. Some candidates applied the formula 1 ˆ sin( ), 2 AB AC BAC ˆ BAC had been found by using the scalar product formula. A few candidates where angle applied 1 (base)(height) after correctly deducing that ABC was isosceles. Common errors 2 included incorrect cross product calculations; finding AB AC even after previously stating a correct formula 1 or misconstruing the area formula as 1 ; 2 AB AC . 2 OA OB Q4(b) proved more challenging since no solution was possible without the application of the scalar triple product. Some candidates used a complete method of applying to find the value of d, although some used 1 1 or 1 instead of 1 . 1 , 21 6 AD AB AC 3 2 6 There were several manipulation and calculation errors seen in the evaluation of the scalar triple 18 0 36 AB AC i j k product in terms of d. Those that used from Q4(a) usually found 3 18 1 d 7 0 21. 6 a correct after solving A common error was the confusion 6 4 36 d between the modulus of a scalar and the magnitude of a vector, leading to some candidates d 2 2 Another common error was to simplify 36 90 (54) (3 144) 126. d writing to d 2 2 give 3 90 (36 ) (90) . d or
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
½ modulus of AB × AC = ½√(18² + 0² + 36²) = 9√5 ≈ 20.1 cm²
using position vectors OA, OB scores 0
cross-product slips and missing ½
June 2019 · Paper 1 (Core Pure 1) · Q7(c)3 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
(c) Most candidates successfully used the dot product to obtain the correct value for cos theta but some failed to give their answer to the nearest degree or used arcsin instead of arccos.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
scalar product of the direction vectors: cos θ = 9/√(14 × 6), θ = 11°
using arcsin or not rounding to the nearest degree
June 2018 · AS Paper 1 (Core Pure) · Q4(a)5 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
(a) Most students appreciated the strategy needed to solve the problem and use the scalar product to find an angle between the normal vector and the direction of W. Unfortunately, many could not then find the required acute angle – a clear diagram would have helped them to visualise which angle was required. A common error was to subtract the result of their inverse cosine from 180°. Those using sine were usually more successful here. A few found the correct angle but failed to give it to the correct accuracy or to indicate degrees or radians and hence lost the final mark.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
angle between line and plane: scalar product of direction (2, 3, 0) with normal then 90° − arccos or use arcsin
7.58° (0.132 rad), units needed
subtracting from 180° was common
June 2018 · AS Paper 2 (Further Pure 1) · Q4(a)3 marks
Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)
Examiner's comment
This question was accessible to most students, but it was clear that there were a few students who had not revised the vector cross product formula. Most students arrived at the given answer in part (a) by applying the method 1 . 2 AB AC Some students found the correct answer by applying the vector cross product between two other edges of triangle ABC. A few students arrived at the given answer by applying the formula 1 ˆ sin( ), 2 AB AC BAC where angle ˆ BAC had been found by using the scalar product formula.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
area = ½ modulus of AB × AC = ½√(74² + 26² + 69²) = 52.2 mm²
sign slips in the cross product (74i − 26j + 69k)
Find an Edexcel Further Maths tutor
Stuck on this? Book a trial lesson with our Further Maths tutor.