Mark scheme (whole question; this part is marked with the orange bar)

Examiner's comment
Although being overall one of the more challenging questions on the paper, this question did give some access to most candidates, but only the better learners were able to produce fully correct solutions. The structure given meant many were able to access all the last part of the question even if falling down on some of the earlier parts. Part (a) was well answered, with most learners showing sufficient evidence of their working. Most learners realised that they needed to work out d d x theta and set it equal to zero, although a small minority mistakenly used d d y theta and were unable to make much progress in this part. Learners who simplified cos (1 sin )cos x r a theta theta theta = = + to (cos 0.5sin 2 ) x a theta theta = + before differentiating tended to perform better overall, as this allowed for a more straightforward differentiation process without having to apply the product rule. Those who did not simplify beforehand gave themselves a more difficult differentiation task, followed by a more complex trigonometric equation to solve, but nevertheless were mostly able to do so correctly. Some candidates struggled to use trigonometric identities to simplify expressions or to solve d 0 d x theta = accurately, with occasional sign or algebraic slips when rearranging. Most candidates went on to find 1 sin 2 theta = or -1, but some failed to consider the geometrical interpretation and reject the sin 1 theta = - equation, giving a point with 3 2 pi theta = . Most candidates were able to proceed to correctly find the value of r for their theta values and so identify the coordinates of A and B, although some did not specify which was which, and some had clearly incompatible coordinates which they did not seem to realise.
Key points from the mark scheme and examiner's report
- x = r cos θ = a(cos θ + ½ sin 2θ)
- dx/dθ = 0 gives 2sin²θ + sin θ − 1 = 0, sin θ = ½ (reject −1)
- A (3a/2, 5π/6), B (3a/2, π/6)
- using dy/dθ made no progress







