Examiner's comment
Examiners commented on the fact that many fully complete and correct responses were seen to this question. However, they further commented that a number of applications of the algorithm in part (a)(i) went wildly awry. This was often precipitated by the first application of stage 10. Most candidates who ended up with approximations to I running into the tens and hundreds of thousands did not seem perturbed, perhaps indicating a lack of engagement with the problem. There were many approaches employed when completing the table and some candidates wasted time filling in every cell for A, B, N, H and C for the first several rows; this did not lose marks but certainly lost time. Others spread their values out across the table with one entry per row which was acceptable. Unfortunately, some candidates omitted key elements of the first and second row completely – quite often, 0 was missing from line one and sometimes 1 from line two. Most candidates worked with decimals with a significant minority using the fraction equivalents. Most candidates kept the output exact following their table, but some used a rounded value in part (b) which usually lost the final accuracy mark. More worryingly, some miscopied or lost digits transferring their answer from part (a) to part (b). It seems evident that candidates are less well prepared for questions such as these involving the application of relatively straightforward (but unseen) algorithms. their approximation from part (a). The vast majority were able to determine the exact value of I although there were a significant number who did not use their calculator and either spent longer than necessary calculating the value or made errors in the integration. Candidates should be advised that in such cases calculator use is perfectly acceptable and, indeed, is advisable. It was surprising the number of candidates who were unable to calculate the percentage error correctly. Despite being GCSE level work, candidates seemed stumped and were creative with their own version of the percentage error formula. Often, the denominator was the approximation rather than the exact answer. Sometimes, candidates simply found the ratio of the exact and approximate value. Others were not alarmed by huge percentage errors obtained by incorrect answers from part (a). The question requested that answers were given to 3 significant figures and a small number of candidates fell at this final hurdle giving answers to just 2 significant figures.