Examiner's comment
This question was understandably quite challenging and did a good job of testing the candidates’ knowledge and skill with estimators. There were a distinct minority of candidates who failed to realise a binomial distribution was required, and hence scored very few marks on this question. Part (d) was definitely the most challenging part of the paper. It required candidates to utilise two criteria for an estimator being valid. While a good number of candidates were able to complete this question well, a lot only used one criterion and hence were not able to form simultaneous equations. If candidates were able to form two equations in a and b there was still much to do. A decent amount of rigour was required to use a correct expression for the variance of the new estimator, combine it with a correct linear equation, form a 3TQ, solve this quadratic to state a range, and interpret the range correctly. This was an appropriate level of challenge to finish the paper, and this part of the question helped to discriminate between the differing ability levels of candidates.